Post Format

‘It WAS NOT your fault’


We asked, and Grace Kim answered. Our call last week for video stories brought this:

We asked her: “What’s been the response so far? And, not an uncommon question: What does your family think?”

Grace, a restaurant owner in the Bay Area, replied by email: “I started out with a blog on Tumblr, and after I received multiple messages about how some of my readers decided not to kill themselves, because of what I was writing, I knew I had to spend all my effort trying to grow my project in order to reach as many people as possible. My family has been oddly supportive. I’m basically what they call a 50-footer in the gay community, you can tell I’m gay from 50 feet away. Everyone always knew I was gay, but I thought I kept my secret well hidden. I just made it way harder on myself than I should’ve, and that’s what most people do.”

Your video stories are welcome.

Meanwhile, the heart of this week’s post is by Christine O’Hagan, a mom, a runner and an executive with an MPA in business. “I would like to do more for depression and suicide awareness now, but it was just a matter of ‘coming out,'” she writes. 

First, the news:

Let’s coin it: “Realcovery.” A remarkable number of first-person stories emerged last week for National Suicide Prevention Week. Much-needed stories like these ought to be called “realcovery,” since they feature real, identifiable people talking openly about coming back from, or learning to deal with, suicidal feelings. Last week’s stories include this one by an attorney and activist, this one about a peer specialist, this one about an Army National Guardsman, this one by a personal grief coach and these special collections of numerous stories from To Write Love on Her Arms, Active Minds and Live Through This.

“When I’m ‘in it,’ no matter how many people tell me ‘this will pass,’ I never believe it,” Cameron Mack wrote for Active Minds. “But there’s a piece of me willing to hang on.”

Here’s Christine:

“There are far, far better things ahead than any we leave behind.” ~ C.S. Lewis

One subject always bouncing around in my head when I was suicidal, more so than the pain of depression and the tiredness of life, was the loved ones I would be leaving behind. I knew that no matter how terrible a person I knew myself to be, and although I was sure everyone was going to be better off without me, they would be sad and they would wonder why I chose to go.

In hearing about those who chose suicide both before and since my own attempt in November 2012, the expressions are always the same: “How selfish of them to do this.” “They had so much to live for.” “Suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem.” “Why didn’t they think of the children/their parents/ their husband/wife?” “Why?”

Before my own attempt, I would raise my voice in agreement. “Yes, how selfish! How could they? I am so angry!” In fact, I had been fighting my own urges to do the same for years. But I felt somewhat superior because, so far, I had managed to avoid acting on it. So I was NOT selfish. Or, at least, I hadn’t been caught.

Since my attempt, and even during my attempt, I have thought about the people who love me and how things would be for them after my life was over. In my extreme depression and pain, I felt that I could not be a good mother, daughter, employee or friend, and this was the kindest thing I could do. I felt they would be grateful for being relieved of having to deal with a person like myself. My kids would be left with my life insurance and would be taken care of through college. My parents were already burdened with my sister, who has asked so much of them with her disabilities. I couldn’t heap anything else on them.

I see things more clearly now and understand the pain I have caused. I see how scared they are for me and know how much worse it would have been if my attempt had gone undiscovered for a few moments more. I have read everything I could get my hands on about the subject of depression and suicide, and I know what that legacy means for children. The last thing I have wanted is for my children to be like me and for them to follow me into that darkness. That would be more of a hell than any I have ever seen in any movie or nightmare.After I was released from the hospital, I willingly gave up the big, beautiful house I had worked so hard for and moved with my children into my parents’ house. This was the first step in helping everyone trust me again. It was not easy for me because I have always been fiercely independent and would never ask anyone for anything. But not asking for help was a huge weakness of mine, so this move was probably good for all of us.

I was still scared of what I had done and didn’t completely trust my own judgement, so anything my therapist and parents advised, I was willing to try. In those first few days and weeks, I concentrated on starting a new routine for the girls and trying to break out of the zombie state I was in, even though sometimes all I could manage was folding laundry and lying on the couch, exhausted.

My favorite time of day was bedtime, but in order to get there, I had to shower. That was my least favorite part of the day because I was exposed to what I had done to myself. The bruises on my neck were still faint, and the wounds on my arms were unavoidable. Until the stitches were removed, I still felt bound to that horrible day. I was becoming more aware of my condition. That it was not normal to feel this way.

My mother and father would ask me questions, trying to understand how I was feeling. I was more than willing to answer anything they asked because I was expecting anger and even anticipating that they would disown me. They gave me complete support and love instead, and that is what ultimately helped me heal so well. I could not have gotten to where I am now without everything they have done for me. They have never, not once, made me feel guilty for what I did. I guess they understand I do a good enough job of that by myself.

My father asked me one morning, as I shuffled around getting the girls’ breakfast and school lunches ready, “Is this hard for you, getting up and doing the morning routine?” I said, “It’s not hard, Dad. It just hurts. Everything hurts. It’s so hard to explain depression. It’s like I have a scuba suit on and I’m at the bottom of the ocean, where it’s dark and there’s all this pressure, and I’m doing everything I am supposed to do at the bottom of the ocean in this scuba suit as fast as I can, but I’m frustrated because it’s difficult and exhausting to even move.” My dad looked at me and said, “I just don’t understand, I guess. I wake up happy every day.” And I said, “Dad, I don’t know that I understand what it feels like to be happy.” He just kind of looked at me like he didn’t understand how that could be possible.

I do know love, though. I remember being small and lying in bed at night, crying, because I loved my parents so much and was afraid they didn’t know how much I loved them. I love my children, without a doubt. I worry about how everything I do and have done affects them. My main motivation for getting well and staying well is them. I suppose saying that I would step in front of a train for them doesn’t have as much weight as if other mothers said it, but how about saying that I would live a long life and die a normal, natural death for them? That, I am working for. And I won’t give that up again.

Two people I know have taken their lives since my attempt. For now, when I hear someone say that they were selfish, I feel compelled to say that they weren’t feeling selfish when they made that choice. They were in more pain than they could bear. They most likely had a mental condition that wouldn’t allow them to see outside of that pain. And I want to tell the ones they left behind, as I want to assure my parents and children, that it WAS NOT your fault this happened. You didn’t miss something. There wasn’t something you could have said or done to make it better, any more than you can cure someone’s cancer.

To those out there like me who are hurting, I understand the pain. I know the cliches you hear from well-meaning friends aren’t making it better. And I know I felt like no one would ever really love me or understand me again, but they did. I know I will be sad again, but it is okay. I know now how to ask for help, and it doesn’t make me weak. You are not weak either. You, too, will be okay.

3 Comments Join the Conversation

  1. Me then (For the first 42 years of my life – specifically surrounding my Ex-Wife’s fight with depression – for which I wish I only knew then, what I know now):
    “I just (didn’t) understand, I guess. I (woke) up happy every day.”

    Me now (about 9 years ago after it totally enveloped me all in one day):
    ” It just hurts. Everything hurts. It’s like I have a scuba suit on and I’m at the bottom of the ocean, where it’s dark and there’s all this pressure, and I’m doing everything I am supposed to do … as fast as I can, but I’m frustrated because it’s difficult and exhausting to even move.”

    (I even know my thoughts and fears and demons are not grounded in reality, but they are still there waiting me for when I awake every day)

    I recently lost my oldest daughter to suicide and find myself at odds with understanding the demons she must have faced, but still hurting deeply over losing her, and yet, I still fight many of the same demons, every… single… day… It just hurts!


  2. I am so sorry to learn of your loss. I can’t imagine what that must be like. Thinking that my children might someday have some of the same feelings I have scare me more than anything else. I have learned that depression can be hereditary and that is a big reason why I felt it was so important for me to start writing about my experiences with depression and my suicide attempt. I don’t want anyone else to be lost to suicide. Not one more person. The only way to reduce the numbers of people who feel so hopeless is to talk about mental health. Your writing what you did is progress. I know it was painful, but someone else will read that, like I did, and relate it to their own life and maybe it will inspire them to talk or write about something, too. This is how healing starts. I heard a quote recently that will stick with me…”Your deepest pain will be your deepest message.” (R.W.) Use this pain to help someone else get through theirs. I bet you will find it just might lessen yours a little. Or maybe even just give you another way to cope with it.

    I found myself having a rough couple of days, today being the worst so far. I have had some changes in my life recently and some memories of my own attempt have resurfaced. I don’t feel like I will make another attempt but I do feel bummed. I came back here to read some of what other people have written and done to overcome their pain. Replying to you has helped me put my situation in perspective a little.

    Like I mentioned in the blog I wrote, E. Feather, it wasn’t your fault your daughter took her life. You were probably a reason she held on as long as she did. Make sure you find someone you can talk to about your own pain. Take good care of yourself and don’t lose faith that as much as you are hurting right now, just concentrate on the little reprieves. The small things that give you comfort until you catch your breath.

    For me, little by little the scuba suit did get a little looser and I was able to enjoy life again. This is something that will always have to be managed but IT CAN be managed. I wish you well…


  3. I get the same response from friends and family, that they just wake up happy. Thank you for writing. I’m not in a good place right now, and I’ve been reading the posts on this site as a means of not acting out. It’s really painful and hard.


Leave a Reply

Required fields are marked *.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s